Skip to content
Forschungsstelle Demokratische Innovationen
Forschungsstelle Demokratische Innovationen
  • Startpage
  • DE
Forschungsstelle Demokratische Innovationen
Forschungsstelle Demokratische Innovationen

Scientific Evaluation of Participatory Budgeting in Frankfurt/Main

cihan,

Duration: May 2011 – May 2014

Funding: City of Frankfurt

Project Leader: Prof. Dr. Brigitte Geißel

Research Staff: Marco Brehme, Alma Kolleck, Martina Neunecker

Evaluation Report on the Participatory Budget in Frankfurt am Main

 

1. The Project in the Context of the Research Unit ‘Democratic Innovations’ The research unit examined democratic innovations from the municipal to the European level and analyzed the emergence, implementation and (lack of) success of these innovations. The starting point was the (presumed) crisis of the representative-democratic system. This crisis found its expression, for example, in declining voter turnout or in the dwindling membership numbers of the political parties. In response to these phenomena, which were also addressed under the catchword of “disenchantment with politics (and politicians)”, new forms of citizen participation have spread, for example the participatory budget.

2. Schedule and Orientation of the Project

The project “The Frankfurt Participatory Budget – Scientific Accompaniment and Evaluation” examined such a democratic innovation at the municipal level. It started in May 2011 under the direction of Prof. Dr. Brigitte Geißel and has scientifically accompanied and evaluated the implementation of the participatory budget in Frankfurt am Main. The most important tasks were, on the one hand, scientific advice on questions of the concrete design, e.g. of individual participation steps. On the other hand, the project evaluated the participatory budget from various perspectives. For example: Is political exchange with non-organized citizens being fostered? Do the participants gain a better understanding of political processes and decisions? What new perspectives do citizens bring to municipal budget planning? The results on the Frankfurt participatory budget were thereby not considered in isolation but in the context of further studies of the research division. The long-term goal is a comprehensive, systematic evaluation of the opportunities and problems of democratic innovations.

3. The Participatory Budget as a Political Instrument

As an innovative instrument, the participatory budget originally comes from Brazil and involves the citizens of a municipality in budget planning. Citizens make proposals on expenditure and savings items and evaluate them. In many other countries, citizens ultimately co-decide on the expenditures. In Germany, the procedure runs differently. Here, the best-rated proposals are submitted to the respective local political decision-making bodies, which do have to account for whether the proposals are retained or implemented, but are not required to implement them in a binding manner.

In Frankfurt, the participatory budget took place between autumn 2011 and spring 2012. In the meantime, it was further developed into an online participation portal.

(See also link: http://www.buergerhaushalt.org/neuigkeiten/evaluation-des-frankfurter-buergerhaushaltes/)

Publications
6615001 DK3CZ9L6 buergerhaushalt-frankfurt_2011 1 chicago-author-date 50 default 650 http://democratic-innovations.de/wp-content/plugins/zotpress/
Presentations
6615001 PFIRZDV7 buergerhaushalt-frankfurt_2011 1 chicago-author-date 50 default 650 http://democratic-innovations.de/wp-content/plugins/zotpress/
Panels
6615001 A9P56VKM buergerhaushalt-frankfurt_2011 1 chicago-author-date 50 default 650 http://democratic-innovations.de/wp-content/plugins/zotpress/
Evaluation Project

Post navigation

Previous post
Next post

Related Posts

Evaluation of the Citizen Dialogue on Sustainable Nutrition (2023-2023)

Leader: Brigitte GeißelTeam: Alan Marx, Rikki Dean Evaluation report (in German)Further information  

Read More

Evaluation of the Citizen Assembly Aachen (2023-2024)

Leader: Brigitte GeißelTeam: Alan Marx Evaluation report (in German)Further information  

Read More

Evaluation of the Citizen Assembly Aachen (2023-2024)

In Kooperation mit der Stadt Aachen Leader: Brigitte GeißelTeam: Alan Marx Evaluation report (in German)Further information  

Read More

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

©2026 Forschungsstelle Demokratische Innovationen | WordPress Theme by SuperbThemes